Business

Why the Best Teams Focus on Solutions, Not Problems

By Michael Watkins and Juan Carlos Holgado

In the final of the 1992 Olympic team archery competition, in front of a home crowd in Barcelona, one of us (Juan Carlos) lost his form. He was Spain’s lead shooter, the arrows were no longer going where he aimed, and the match was still in progress.

That was a problem with no solution, because you can’t rebuild an archer’s form in the middle of an Olympic final. So the team spent no time on it. Juan Carlos pulled his two teammates aside, gave up the lead position, and moved to the middle of the order (the place normally given to the weakest shooter). A teammate stepped up, and Spain beat Finland by two points to win the gold medal.

Join The European Business Briefing

New subscribers this quarter are entered into a draw to win a Rolex Submariner. Join 40,000+ founders, investors and executives who read EBM every day.

Subscribe

Archers learn a rule that covers this: focus on solutions, not on problems, and if there is no solution, there is no problem. Unfortunately, it is easy to mistake this rule for some of the worst advice in management.

 

 

What the Rule Does Not Say

Many leaders are proud of the line “Bring me solutions, not problems,” and it does a lot of damage, because people who can’t solve a problem learn not to mention it. So if you use it, bad news will reach you late or not at all, and you will go on believing that things are fine.

The archers’ rule says something else, and Barcelona shows the difference. Juan Carlos brought his teammates a problem he could not solve. He had to say, in an Olympic final, that he was not shooting well enough to lead. But a year earlier he would not have said it. The three archers were barely speaking then, so his teammates would have taken the admission as surrender, and he would have hidden the problem until it cost them the medal.

This means the rule governs what the team does once a problem has been raised. Anyone may raise one, whether or not they have an answer in hand. Juan Carlos stated his problem once, and everything after that was about what could be done.

Problems and Conditions

Michael Watkins

To apply the rule, you first have to sort what you are facing into problems and conditions. A problem is something you can influence, and it gets your full attention; a condition is something you can’t influence (like the weather), and you plan around it. An archer can’t stop the wind, but she can change her aim point, her timing, and her expectations, so those are what she thinks about.

Juan Carlos’s lost form was a condition. The shooting order was a problem, because it had a solution. A team that can tell the two apart quickly can keep most of its attention on what it can change.

Business works the same way. Suppose your largest customer has left for a competitor, and the decision is final. The loss is now a condition, however much it hurts, and the time you spend on how it happened will change nothing about it unless it produces something you will do differently. Your problems are the ones that still have solutions (for example, finding out which of your other accounts carry the same risk, and deciding what to do with the capacity that customer used).

Why do many leadership teams find this hard? Because talking about problems feels like rigor. If your team spends most of a meeting on why the launch slipped and whose forecast was wrong, the meeting feels serious, but much of it concerns things that none of you can now change. Of course, some of that talk is diagnosis, which identifies what broke specifically enough to act on, and it doesn’t have to take long. The rest goes over the same ground without getting anywhere, and there often is more of it under pressure, because explaining a problem is safer than proposing what to do about it.

Building the Habit

Three practices can help you build this habit in your team.

Juan Carlos

Make it safe to bring a problem without an answer. It’s essential to do this first, because the other two practices depend on it. How you respond the first time someone says “I have a problem and I don’t know what to do about it” will largely determine whether anyone on your team says it again. Thank them, ask them to state the problem as clearly as they can, and then move the team to the next question. If you answer with a sigh or with “So what do you propose?”, you teach your team to stay quiet.

Sort before you discuss. The next question is always the same: What here can we influence? Whatever your team can’t influence is a condition, so say that aloud and stop spending time on it. The same applies afterward. When your team has done what it could and the result is still poor, keep in mind the archers’ three-step practice for the arrow that has gone: notice, release, start over. For your team, that means acknowledging the poor result, accepting that it is now a condition, and turning to the next problem you can influence.

Hold back your own solution. Capable leaders often fall into a trap here. Your team likely will learn to wait for you if you answer every problem as soon as it is raised. Three questions can do more than your answer would: What have you already tried? What is stopping you from testing your preferred solution? If this were your call alone, what would you do? Sometimes your team still needs your expertise, and then you add it to their thinking.

The best teams focus on solutions because their members can first say what is wrong, even when they have no idea how to fix it. In your next meeting, when someone raises a problem, pay attention to your first reaction. Then ask what your team can influence and spend your time on that.

The Archer’s Edge: Ancient Wisdom and Modern Practice for Business Leaders by Michael Watkins and Juan Carlos Holgado is published by Wiley, priced £32.99

About the authors

Michael D. Watkins is Professor of Leadership and Organizational Change at IMD and co-founder of Genesis Advisers. He is the author of The First 90 Days and The Six Disciplines of Strategic Thinking, and co-author of The Archer’s Edge. He was inducted into the Thinkers50 Hall of Fame in 2023.

Juan Carlos Holgado is Executive Director of World Archery. He won an Olympic team gold medal for Spain at Barcelona in 1992, went to four Games as athlete and coach, and was founding director of the World Archery Excellence Centre in Lausanne. He is co-author of The Archer’s Edge.

EBM Newsdesk

The central editorial desk for European Business Magazine, delivering daily aggregated global corporate insights, market analytics, and macro-industrial updates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *