Business

Payment Processing Mistakes That Could Be Costing Your Online Store Sales

Updated

The Federal Trade Commission’s Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees took effect on May 12, 2025, and it requires sellers of live-event tickets and short-term lodging to show the total price up front. The rule covers only those 2 sectors, yet the practice it targets appears on many other online stores, where a shipping charge or a handling fee first appears on the last screen. A shopper who meets that charge has already decided to buy, and the new total reopens the decision.

Extra Costs at the Final Step

Baymard Institute’s 2026 survey found that 40% of US online shoppers had abandoned a purchase because extra costs such as shipping, taxes, or fees were too high. Another 12% left because they could not see or calculate the total cost in advance. Baymard’s average cart abandonment rate across 50 studies is 70.22%, and although some of those carts were never serious purchases, these 2 causes are within a store’s control.

Shipping estimates on the product page, or a calculator in the cart, move the information to a point where the shopper can still adjust the order. A store that cannot offer free shipping can set a minimum order for it, which gives the shopper a reason to add an item.

Join The European Business Briefing

New subscribers this quarter are entered into a draw to win a Rolex Submariner. Join 40,000+ founders, investors and executives who read EBM every day.

Subscribe

Overly Strict Fraud Filters

Default fraud settings are written for an average merchant. A store selling inexpensive candles and a store selling $3,000 cameras face different risks, yet both often use the same address and security code rules on the day they launch. Rules that are too strict reject good customers, and those customers seldom call to explain what happened.

Reviewing declined orders by rule each month shows which filter is costing the most sales.

Uninformative Decline Messages

A message that says only that the transaction failed gives a shopper nothing to act on. Banks return codes that distinguish an expired card from insufficient funds or a suspected fraud flag. A checkout can translate those codes into a plain instruction, such as asking the shopper to check the expiration date. Messages should avoid naming fraud directly, because a shopper accused of fraud rarely returns, and the form should keep every field the shopper has already typed.

Post-Launch Settings Review

Payment processing settings chosen at launch are rarely revisited, even after order volume and customer location have changed. A store that began with domestic orders may now sell abroad without having enabled a multicurrency option, so foreign shoppers see an unfamiliar price and pay a conversion fee to their bank.

The name that appears on a customer’s card statement is another setting that gets ignored. If the statement shows a parent company or an abbreviation the customer does not recognize, the customer may dispute a legitimate charge, and each dispute costs the merchant a fee along with the lost sale.

Dispute Ratio Monitoring

Card networks watch the share of a merchant’s transactions that end in a dispute. A high ratio can lead to a monitoring program with added fees and, in the worst case, the loss of the account. Many small stores learn about this only when a warning arrives from the provider. A store should calculate its dispute ratio each month, respond to every dispute before the deadline, and keep delivery confirmation for each shipped order so the evidence is ready when a claim comes in.

Order Confirmation and Receipts

A confirmation email that arrives late prompts a duplicate order or a support ticket from a shopper who is unsure the purchase went through. The message should go out within seconds and include the order number, the amount charged, the last 4 digits of the card, and the name that will appear on the statement. Those details answer most of the questions that would otherwise reach the support inbox.

Expired Cards and Failed Renewals

Stores that sell subscriptions or replenishment orders lose revenue when a stored card expires. Automatic card updater services replace old card details with the new ones issued by the bank. A retry schedule can attempt a failed charge again on the days a customer is more likely to have funds. Canceling a subscription after a single failed retry ends the relationship with a customer who never chose to leave.

Smartphone Checkout Testing

Smartphone shopping is widespread, and a Pew Research Center survey published in 2022 found that 76% of US adults buy things online using a phone, compared with 69% who use a desktop or laptop computer. A checkout tested only on a large monitor may have card fields that are too small to tap or a keyboard that covers the submit button. Testing on actual phones before each release costs little and finds problems a desktop preview will not show.

Site Errors During Peak Demand

Baymard’s survey found that 17% of shoppers had abandoned an order because the website had errors or crashed. Black Friday and similar events concentrate orders into a few hours. A checkout that works at normal volume can fail when a promotional email management reaches the whole list at once. A store should test the checkout under heavy load before a major sale and confirm with its provider what transaction limits apply to its account, since an unexpected spike in volume can trigger a hold on payouts.

Returns and Refund Handling

Baymard found that 13% of shoppers had abandoned a purchase over an unsatisfactory return policy, and retailers have responded in different ways to the cost of returned goods. Some now offer returnless refunds, and others charge a fee for each return.

Refunds should go back to the original card as soon as the item is inspected, with a message stating the date. A tighter policy also answers a real problem, since return fraud costs retailers billions of dollars, and a store can treat a first-time return differently from a repeat claim.

Monthly Fee Statement Review

Monthly statements show the rate paid on each card type. Unread statements hide any rise in the store’s effective rate. Dividing total fees by total card sales each month produces a single figure that can be tracked over the course of a year. A jump in that figure usually means a new fee or an expired contract term, and a call to the provider can settle it.

 

A Failed-Order Review

After a busy weekend, the owner of a small online store opens the failed orders and sorts them by reason. Most of them share a single address-matching rule, so the owner loosens it, moves the shipping estimate to the product page, and changes the statement name to match the store. A week later the failed-order list is shorter, and the owner has a dated record of each change to compare against the next month’s sales.

Nick Staunton

Nick Staunton is the Editor and Chief Executive of European Business Magazine, one of Europe's leading business and geopolitical analysis publications. He writes primarily on European markets, fintech, defence industry consolidation, and the business impact of geopolitical events. Nick has over a decade of experience in digital publishing and holds editorial responsibility for EBM's coverage of European rearmament, the Iran war's economic consequences, and the structural shifts reshaping European capital markets. He is based in the United Kingdom and is also Chief Executive of NST Publishing Ltd, the parent company of European Business Magazine

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *